Same and Different: Grades 3-5

  • Game
  • 3–5
  • 10 pages · 10 min

10 harder comparisons: a whale and a shark, a river and a lake, a library and a bookstore, a map and a globe and more. Built for grades 3–5, it works in pull-out, push-in, or teletherapy, with 10 screens, in about 10 minutes. Skill tags on this board: compare and contrast, verbal reasoning, vocabulary. Plays in the browser with no login; add students to score trials against IEP goals.

Quiz

Same and Different: Grades 3-5

How are a whale and a shark the same?

Tap your answer.

Demo — these marks stay on this screen.Save these marks to a student, free →Sign in

Session summary (SOAP)

Stays on this screen. Nothing is saved or sent.

Mark a card Correct, Correct with cue or Incorrect and the summary writes itself here.

How to run it

Use a two-circle diagram. After each answer, ask the student to add one more similarity or difference of their own. With the whale and shark pair, talk about how two things can look alike and still belong to different groups.

Cueing ladder

Start at the top. Add support one step at a time.

  1. Step 1IndependentPresent the item and wait 5 seconds of quiet before helping.Log as correct
  2. Step 2HintGive a clue about the word's category, what it does, or where you find it.Log as cued
  3. Step 3Two choicesOffer two answers, the right one not always second.Log as cued
  4. Step 4ModelGive the answer in a sentence; the student says it back and uses it once more.Log as cued

Adjust it

Easier

Use fewer items and start with the ones the student already knows.

Harder

Ask for the word in a sentence of the student's own, or a second example from the same group.

Matching IEP goal

Given vocabulary cards, Student will name, sort or define target words in 8 of 10 opportunities across 3 consecutive sessions, given no more than an indirect cue.

Send it home through the parent portal →

About this activity

Ten comparisons for upper elementary, many drawn from science and social studies: a whale and a shark, a river and a lake, a library and a bookstore, a map and a globe, a desert and a rainforest. The wrong choices are things true of only one of the pair or of neither, so the student has to test each choice against both things.

What to listen for

Notice whether the student checks a choice against both items. 'Both breathe air' for a whale and a shark is a common trap. Ask the student to say a compare sentence using both and but, which shows whether they can hold the two ideas together.

Carrying it home

When reading or watching something together, pick two characters or places and ask how they are alike and how they are different. Use 'both' and 'but' in your answers.

What's in this activity

  • How are a whale and a shark the same?
    • both live in the ocean
    • both breathe air
    • both are fish
  • How are a whale and a shark different?
    • a shark lives in water
    • a whale breathes air
    • a whale can swim
  • How are a river and a lake different?
    • a lake has water
    • a river is wet
    • a river flows along
  • How are a library and a bookstore the same?
    • both have books
    • both sell books
    • both lend books
  • How are a library and a bookstore different?
    • both have shelves
    • you borrow from a library
    • both have books
  • How are a map and a globe different?
    • a map shows places
    • a globe shows land
    • a globe is round
  • How are a frog and a toad the same?
    • both are amphibians
    • both are reptiles
    • both live only in trees
  • How are a desert and a rainforest different?
    • a desert has plants
    • a rainforest gets much more rain
    • both are hot
  • How are a piano and a guitar the same?
    • both have keys
    • both have strings you pluck
    • both are instruments
  • How are a thermometer and a ruler the same?
    • both measure things
    • both measure heat
    • both measure length

Questions

Why science and social studies pairs?
Classroom writing asks for comparisons like these, so practising with class topics helps the skill carry over.
What sentence frame helps?
'Both ___ and ___ are ___, but ___.' It holds the similarity and the difference in one sentence.

Use this board with your caseload

With a free account, every correct, cued and incorrect mark is saved to the student and scored against their IEP goal, with the data written up for you. Assign it as home practice through the parent portal.

Track progress free

Free for SLPs. No card, no trial clock.