Taking a Stand: Position and Reason

  • Game
  • 6–12
  • 10 pages · 10 min

10 questions about stating a position with a reason, disagreeing respectfully and changing your mind when the evidence changes. Built for grades 6–12, it works in pull-out, push-in, or teletherapy, with 10 screens, in about 10 minutes. Skill tags on this board: argument, perspective taking, discussion. Plays in the browser with no login; add students to score trials against IEP goals.

Quiz

Taking a Stand: Position and Reason

Which sentence states a clear position with a reason?

Tap your answer.

Demo — these marks stay on this screen.Save these marks to a student, free →Sign in

Session summary (SOAP)

Stays on this screen. Nothing is saved or sent.

Mark a card Correct, Correct with cue or Incorrect and the summary writes itself here.

How to run it

After each answer, have the student use the sentence frame on a real topic. Then hold a short two-minute discussion on one topic, with the student taking a position, giving a reason and answering one comeback. Swap sides and try again.

Cueing ladder

Start at the top. Add support one step at a time.

  1. Step 1IndependentSet up the situation and wait for the student to respond on their own.Log as correct
  2. Step 2Nonverbal cueUse a look, a gesture or a point to the visual cue card.Log as cued
  3. Step 3Indirect promptAsk 'What could you say now?' or 'How do you think they feel?'Log as cued
  4. Step 4ModelShow what to say or do, then run the moment again so the student can try it.Log as cued

Adjust it

Easier

Give a script or two choices of what to say, and practise with you before a peer.

Harder

Role-play with a new partner, or add a twist the student has not planned for.

Matching IEP goal

Given social scenarios, Student will identify another person's thoughts or feelings and give a reason in 8 of 10 opportunities across 3 consecutive sessions, given no more than an indirect prompt.

Send it home through the parent portal →

About this activity

Ten questions about taking part in a discussion where there is no single right answer. The student picks the sentence that states a position with a reason, a respectful way to disagree, a good follow-up question, a way to say you are somewhere in between, and a way to change your mind when new facts come in. Topics are everyday school ones: phones in class, homework, a longer lunch.

What to listen for

Notice whether the student can give a reason and not just a position. Watch for rude or dismissive choices, and for students who always choose 'totally agree' to avoid conflict. Being able to say 'I used to think' is a sign of flexible thinking.

Carrying it home

At dinner, pick a light topic and ask each person to take a side and give one reason. Practise saying 'I see your point, but...' and 'I used to think..., but now...'

What's in this activity

  • Which sentence states a clear position with a reason?
    • I think phones should be put away in class because they distract me
    • Phones I guess
    • Whatever everyone thinks
  • Which is a respectful way to disagree?
    • That is a dumb idea
    • I see your point but I disagree because
    • You are wrong
  • Your friend says homework should be banned. What is a good follow-up question?
    • Why are you like this
    • Who cares
    • What would help students practise instead
  • Which sentence shows you are somewhere in between?
    • I agree with part of that but not all of it
    • I totally agree
    • I totally disagree
  • New facts change your mind. What can you say?
    • I was never wrong
    • I used to think that but now I think
    • Facts don't matter
  • Which reason is strongest for a longer lunch?
    • it would be fun
    • I want it
    • students would have time to eat and rest
  • Someone says your idea costs too much. What could you do?
    • suggest a cheaper version
    • get angry
    • give up right away
  • Which sentence starter helps you give a reason?
    • Everyone knows
    • One reason I think this is
    • Because I said so
  • Which shows you listened to the other side?
    • I did not hear you
    • Anyway
    • You said lunch is short. I agree but
  • In a discussion with no right answer what matters most?
    • explaining your reasons clearly
    • winning
    • talking the loudest

Questions

Is there a right answer to the topics?
No. The questions are about how to state and discuss a view, not which view is correct.
Why include changing your mind?
Being able to update a view with new facts is part of a good discussion, not a weakness.

Use this board with your caseload

With a free account, every correct, cued and incorrect mark is saved to the student and scored against their IEP goal, with the data written up for you. Assign it as home practice through the parent portal.

Track progress free

Free for SLPs. No card, no trial clock.