Defend Your Side: The Strongest Reason

  • Game
  • 6–12
  • 10 pages · 10 min

10 debate moments: pick the strongest reason for a side, then the best answer to a comeback. Built for grades 6–12, it works in pull-out, push-in, or teletherapy, with 10 screens, in about 10 minutes. Skill tags on this board: argument, verbal reasoning, persuasion. Plays in the browser with no login; add students to score trials against IEP goals.

Quiz

Defend Your Side: The Strongest Reason

Your side is that school should start later. Which reason is strongest?

Tap your answer.

Demo — these marks stay on this screen.Save these marks to a student, free →Sign in

Session summary (SOAP)

Stays on this screen. Nothing is saved or sent.

Mark a card Correct, Correct with cue or Incorrect and the summary writes itself here.

How to run it

After each pair, have the student argue the side aloud using the reason and the comeback answer. Then argue the other side together. The silly cereal debate is a good warm-up because nobody is attached to an answer and the reasoning is easy to see.

Cueing ladder

Start at the top. Add support one step at a time.

  1. Step 1IndependentSet up the situation and wait for the student to respond on their own.Log as correct
  2. Step 2Nonverbal cueUse a look, a gesture or a point to the visual cue card.Log as cued
  3. Step 3Indirect promptAsk 'What could you say now?' or 'How do you think they feel?'Log as cued
  4. Step 4ModelShow what to say or do, then run the moment again so the student can try it.Log as cued

Adjust it

Easier

Give a script or two choices of what to say, and practise with you before a peer.

Harder

Role-play with a new partner, or add a twist the student has not planned for.

Matching IEP goal

In structured role-plays, Student will use the target conversation skill appropriately in 4 of 5 opportunities across 3 consecutive sessions, given no more than a nonverbal cue.

Send it home through the parent portal →

About this activity

Ten debate moments on topics from serious to silly: a later school start, a salad bar, pets in dorms and whether cereal is a soup. For each side the student picks the strongest reason, then the best answer to a comeback written against it, such as buses costing more or allergies. The last two questions ask what makes a reason weak and a comeback answer strong.

What to listen for

Notice whether the student picks reasons that could be checked or shown, over opinions and popularity. Watch the comeback answers for ones that respond to the exact point; changing the subject or denying the point are the common weak moves.

Carrying it home

Hold a silly family debate (Is a hot dog a sandwich?) where each person gives a reason and answers one comeback. Praise strong reasons, not the winner.

What's in this activity

  • Your side is that school should start later. Which reason is strongest?
    • students would get more sleep before class
    • it would be cool
    • my friends say so
  • Comeback says buses would cost more. Which answer is best?
    • nobody cares about buses
    • the schedule could shift without new buses
    • that is not true
  • Your side is that the cafeteria should have a salad bar. Which reason is strongest?
    • salads are green
    • I like salad
    • more students would eat vegetables
  • Comeback says salad bars waste food. Which answer is best?
    • start small and track what is eaten
    • food waste is fine
    • you are wrong
  • Your side is that pets should be allowed in dorms. Which reason is strongest?
    • pets are cute
    • pets can lower stress for students
    • everyone wants one
  • Comeback says some students are allergic. Which answer is best?
    • allergies are not real
    • they can move out
    • have pet-free floors
  • Your side is that cereal is a soup. Which reason is strongest?
    • it is food in a liquid in a bowl
    • it is breakfast
    • it tastes good
  • Comeback says soup is usually hot. Which answer is best?
    • cereal is hot
    • cold soups like gazpacho exist
    • soup is boring
  • Which reason is weakest in any debate?
    • a fact you can check
    • an example from real life
    • everyone knows it
  • What makes a comeback answer strong?
    • it responds to the exact point
    • it is loud
    • it changes the subject

Questions

Why silly topics?
With no stakes, the student can focus on the shape of a good reason.
What makes a reason strong?
It can be checked or shown with an example, and it is about the topic, not about who agrees.

Use this board with your caseload

With a free account, every correct, cued and incorrect mark is saved to the student and scored against their IEP goal, with the data written up for you. Assign it as home practice through the parent portal.

Track progress free

Free for SLPs. No card, no trial clock.