
Compare Two Options and Explain
- Game
- 6–9
- 1 page · 10 min
Twelve teen dilemmas for compare-and-explain talk: presenting first or last, redoing a slide vs. turning it in, asking a teacher vs. messaging later, joining a club alone vs. waiting, the late bus vs. missing practice, speaking up now vs. waiting, group study vs. reviewing alone, naming a hurt vs. letting it go, a harder class vs. GPA, staying to clean up vs. leaving, posting vs. talking first, and asking for an extension vs. staying up. The student should pick one option and give at least two reasons, using because, so, or a contrast ("I'd rather..., because..."). There isn't one right pick — the language goal…
Talk about it
Compare Two Options and Explain
12 cards — tap to deal
How to run it
Deal one card at a time. The student looks at the picture and says the word or sentence on the card before you move on. You judge the production or the language form yourself; the cards advance either way. Work through the set once for a baseline, then return to the cards that were hard. Keep your own data: mark independent, cued, or modeled trials in your session notes. If the student is tired, do a shorter set rather than rushing the last cards.
Cueing ladder
Start at the top. Add support one step at a time.
- IndependentPresent the item and wait 5 seconds of quiet before helping.Log as correct
- HintStress the part of the sentence that changes, or point to the word ending or picture clue.Log as cued
- Sentence starterSay the first half of the sentence and let the student finish it.Log as cued
- ModelSay the correct form in the whole sentence; the student repeats it.Log as cued
Adjust it
Give a sentence starter every time, and do fewer cards.
Ask for a new sentence of the student's own with the same form, with no card to lean on.
Matching IEP goal
Given sentence or picture cards, Student will produce the target language form or response in 8 of 10 opportunities across 3 consecutive sessions, given no more than an indirect cue.
Send it home through the parent portal →About this activity
Compare Two Options and Explain is a English speaking cards board for middle and high school students. Twelve teen dilemmas for compare-and-explain talk: presenting first or last, redoing a slide vs. turning it in, asking a teacher vs. messaging later, joining a club alone vs. waiting, the late bus vs. missing practice, speaking up now vs. waiting, group study vs. reviewing alone, naming a hurt vs. letting it go, a harder class vs. GPA, staying to clean up vs. leaving, posting vs. talking first, and asking for an extension vs. staying up. The student should pick one option and give at least two reasons, using because, so, or a contrast ("I'd rather..., because..."). There isn't one right pick — the language goal is a clear comparison.
What to listen for
Listen and watch for the skill named in the description, not only whether the student finishes the board. Notice whether errors cluster on certain items (for example Would you rather present first or last and why?) or show up across the set. For pictured items, confirm the student is talking about the picture you meant. If a listening item is missed, replay it once before you show the words. Write down the cue level that made the next try successful so you can fade it next session.
Carrying it home
Pick three items from the board and use them in a real routine at home or in class the same day. An adult can show the picture, wait, and then model the word or sentence if needed. Keep practice short and specific: one or two minutes on Would you rather present first or last and why? is enough. If you send the link home, tell families the board is a practice tool, not a test, and that the SLP will interpret the responses.
What's in this activity
- Would you rather present first or last and why?
- Would you rather redo a slide tonight or turn in a weaker draft on time and why?
- Would you rather ask a teacher after class or send a message later and why?
- Would you rather join a new club alone or wait until a friend can join too and why?
- Would you rather take the late bus or miss practice to catch the regular bus and why?
- Would you rather speak up about a group problem now or wait and see and why?
- Would you rather study with a group or review alone the night before a test and why?
- Would you rather tell a friend they hurt you or let it go this time and why?
- Would you rather take a harder class that you care about or an easier one that protects your GPA and why?
- Would you rather stay and help clean up after an event or leave when your ride arrives and why?
- Would you rather post about a conflict or talk to the person first and why?
- Would you rather ask for an extension or stay up and finish and why?
Questions
- Who is this for?
- This board is for middle and high school students working on the skills in the description, including Would you rather present first or last and why?, Would you rather redo a slide tonight or turn in a weaker draft on time and why?, Would you rather ask a teacher after class or send a message later and why?, Would you rather join a new club alone or wait until a friend can join too and why?, Would you rather take the late bus or miss practice to catch the regular bus and why?, and Would you rather speak up about a group problem now or wait and see and why?.
- Is it free?
- Yes. It plays free in the browser with no login. An account adds session data, goal scoring, and assignment to a student.
- Can I change the items?
- Yes. Copy the activity to your library or rebuild the list in Activity Studio with the same template. Keep the same target and grade band so the pictures and wording still fit.
Use this board with your caseload
With a free account, every correct, cued and incorrect mark is saved to the student and scored against their IEP goal, with the data written up for you. Assign it as home practice through the parent portal.
Track progress freeFree for SLPs. No card, no trial clock.