Case of the Missing Pie

  • Game
  • 6–10
  • 9 pages · 10 min

A three-part listening mystery for middle and high school: a timeline, three statements and the clues that show who moved the pie, where and why. Built for grades 6–10, it works in pull-out, push-in, or teletherapy, with 9 screens, in about 10 minutes. Sample stimuli: When did the pie go missing?, Why did he take it?. Plays in the browser with no login; add students to score trials against IEP goals.

Quiz

Case of the Missing Pie

This device has no voice — read the passage aloud to the student.

At 3 o'clock Mr. Hale set a cherry pie on the windowsill to cool. At 3:30 his daughter Nell came home from soccer with muddy cleats. At 3:45 the neighbor's dog was barking in the yard. At 4 o'clock Mr. Hale went to get the pie and the windowsill was empty. There was a trail of red crumbs across the kitchen floor and a smear of cherry on the handle of the back door.

Where was the pie before it went missing?

Tap your answer.

Demo — these marks stay on this screen.Save these marks to a student, free →Sign in

Session summary (SOAP)

Stays on this screen. Nothing is saved or sent.

Mark a card Correct, Correct with cue or Incorrect and the summary writes itself here.

How to run it

Play each part with the words hidden and let the student take notes on a timeline. Before each set of questions, ask what the student thinks happened so far and why. In the last part, insist on two clues for the answer, then have the student explain the whole case aloud in order, as a detective would.

Cueing ladder

Start at the top. Add support one step at a time.

  1. Step 1IndependentPresent the item and wait 5 seconds of quiet before helping.Log as correct
  2. Step 2HintReread the key sentence, or point back to the clue in the text or picture.Log as cued
  3. Step 3Two choicesOffer two answers, the right one not always second.Log as cued
  4. Step 4ModelThink aloud: say how you worked it out, then the student says the answer and why.Log as cued

Adjust it

Easier

Read it aloud to the student and offer two choices from the start.

Harder

Ask the student to say which words gave them the clue, not just the answer.

Matching IEP goal

Given short texts or spoken prompts, Student will make an inference and say which clue they used in 8 of 10 opportunities across 3 consecutive sessions, given no more than an indirect cue.

Send it home through the parent portal →

About this activity

A mystery in three spoken parts. First the timeline: a cherry pie cools on a windowsill and is gone an hour later, with crumbs and a cherry smear on the back door handle. Then three statements, from Nell, Theo and the neighbor, and two details that do not fit one of them. Last, the pie dish behind the shed and a note. Nine questions ask where, when, whose story does not hold up, and which two clues prove it.

What to listen for

Notice whether the student uses the clues or jumps to a favorite suspect. Choosing Nell because of the muddy cleats shows attention to detail but not to what the detail proves. The clue questions show whether the student can link evidence to a conclusion.

Carrying it home

Make up a tiny mystery at home: hide a snack and leave two clues. Let your teen work out what happened and explain which clues they used. Then swap and have them set one for you.

What's in this activity

  • Where was the pie before it went missing?
    • on the windowsill
    • in the oven
    • on the table outside
  • Which clue shows the pie went out of the back door?
    • the muddy cleats
    • cherry on the back door handle
    • the barking dog
  • When did the pie go missing?
    • before 3 o'clock
    • after dinner
    • between 3 and 4 o'clock
  • Whose statement does the open book make doubtful?
    • Theo's
    • Nell's
    • the neighbor's
  • Why does the red stain matter?
    • it shows Theo was cold
    • it could be cherry from the pie
    • it means the book was new
  • Which statement is not contradicted by any clue so far?
    • Theo's
    • none of them
    • the neighbor's
  • Who most likely moved the pie?
    • Theo
    • Nell
    • the dog
  • Why did he take it?
    • to hide it from the dog
    • to share at a picnic with friends
    • to throw it away
  • Which two clues best support the answer?
    • the muddy cleats and the shower
    • the barking and the windowsill
    • the note handwriting and the red sleeve

Questions

Why listening and not reading?
Holding a timeline in mind while listening is harder and closer to following a teacher's explanation. Replay any part as often as needed.
What is the main skill?
Explaining a conclusion with evidence: what happened, and which clues show it.

Use this board with your caseload

With a free account, every correct, cued and incorrect mark is saved to the student and scored against their IEP goal, with the data written up for you. Assign it as home practice through the parent portal.

Track progress free

Free for SLPs. No card, no trial clock.