
Supported or Not? Checking a Claim
- Game
- 9–12
- 10 pages · 10 min
10 claims with the evidence behind them. Decide whether each is supported, misleading, contradicted or not established. Built for grades 9–12, it works in pull-out, push-in, or teletherapy, with 10 screens, in about 10 minutes. Skill tags on this board: evidence, critical thinking, media literacy. Plays in the browser with no login; add students to score trials against IEP goals.
Quiz
Supported or Not? Checking a Claim
Records show 2000 pool visits in June and 3000 in July. Claim says pool visits went up in July.
Tap your answer.
Session summary (SOAP)
Stays on this screen. Nothing is saved or sent.
Mark a card Correct, Correct with cue or Incorrect and the summary writes itself here.
How to run it
Read the evidence first and the claim second. Ask the student what the facts given actually say before they choose. After each answer, have the student rewrite the claim so it matches the evidence, using careful words like some, most or in July. Point out that 'not established' is not the same as 'false'.
Cueing ladder
Start at the top. Add support one step at a time.
- IndependentPresent the item and wait 5 seconds of quiet before helping.Log as correct
- HintRephrase the prompt and point to the part that matters.Log as cued
- Two choicesOffer two answers, the right one not always second.Log as cued
- ModelGive the answer; the student says it back in their own words.Log as cued
Adjust it
Use fewer items and offer two choices from the start.
Ask for a full-sentence answer and a reason.
Matching IEP goal
Given the activity prompts, Student will respond correctly in 8 of 10 opportunities across 3 consecutive sessions, given no more than an indirect cue.
Send it home through the parent portal →About this activity
Ten claims, each with the evidence behind it. The student decides whether the evidence supports the claim, contradicts it, makes it misleading or simply does not establish it. One student feeling sick after the tacos does not establish that the tacos make students sick; ice cream and sunburn rising together does not mean one causes the other. Two last questions ask for an accurate headline and a careful word.
What to listen for
Notice whether the student can tell misleading from contradicted. Misleading claims stretch true facts; contradicted claims are shown wrong. Watch the correlation item: a student who calls it supported needs the idea that two things rising together can share a cause.
Carrying it home
When you see a headline or an ad at home, ask your teen what evidence would support it, and whether the claim says more than the evidence does. Rewrite one together in fewer, more careful words.
What's in this activity
- Records show 2000 pool visits in June and 3000 in July. Claim says pool visits went up in July.
- supported
- misleading
- contradicted
- not established
- One student felt sick after the cafeteria tacos. Claim says the tacos make students sick.
- supported
- not established
- misleading
- contradicted
- The bus was late on 2 of 20 school days. Claim says the bus is almost always late.
- Ice cream sales and sunburns both rise in summer. Claim says ice cream causes sunburn.
- supported
- contradicted
- not established
- misleading
- A phone ad says up to two days of battery. Claim says every user gets two days.
- misleading
- supported
- contradicted
- not established
- City records list 12 new trees planted on Main Street. Claim says the city planted trees on Main Street.
- A singer says a shampoo works. Claim says scientists proved the shampoo works.
- supported
- misleading
- not established
- contradicted
- The team lost 9 of 10 games. Claim says the team had a winning season.
- Which headline fits the pool records best?
- Everyone in town swims now
- Pool to close next month
- Pool visits rose from June to July
- Which word makes a claim more careful?
- some
- all
- always
Questions
- What do the four verdicts mean?
- Supported: the evidence backs it. Misleading: true facts stretched too far. Contradicted: the facts given prove it wrong. Not established: not enough evidence either way.
- Why rewrite the claim?
- Saying a more accurate version is the language skill; choosing the verdict is the reasoning.
Use this board with your caseload
With a free account, every correct, cued and incorrect mark is saved to the student and scored against their IEP goal, with the data written up for you. Assign it as home practice through the parent portal.
Track progress freeFree for SLPs. No card, no trial clock.